Need a cardamom substitute? Here are 7 common spices that have warming, spicy, sharp, zesty, or earthy flavor profiles and can mimic cardamom’s unique flavor.

black and green cardamom

A recipe you’re making calls for cardamom and you’ve got zilch. So, what can you use in place of cardamom that won’t drastically alter the taste of your dish?

When it comes to the best cardamom substitute, I’ve compiled a few different combinations of common, inexpensive spices that can mimic the taste. Most of them are easy to find at your local grocery store. Plus, with cardamom being one of the most expensive spices in the world (next to saffron and vanilla bean) it also doesn’t hurt to try these combinations if you’re being mindful of your budget.

Before we jump into the best cardamom substitutes, it helps to understand the flavor profile and various dishes that cardamom is used in so that you can choose the right substitute for your sweet or savory recipes.

What Is Cardamom?

Cardamom is a pungent, complex spice used widely in Indian and Arabic cuisine, both in sweet and savory dishes, such as puddings, chai, lentil stews or curry chicken, and red meat and seafood dishes. In its whole form, cardamom is found in green, black, or white pods, or you can buy it ground.

At first glance, cardamom pods and seeds kind of resemble almonds and miniature pumpkin seeds. Cardamom belongs to the turmeric and ginger family, spices that are known for their “bite” and sharp, spicy flavor profiles, and warming properties.

Cardamom has Egyptian and Southern Indian roots, and it is used liberally in Middle Eastern and Indian cooking. The history of cardamom dates all the way back to ancient Egypt, where cardamom pods were actually used as pseudo-breath mints and natural oral care! In fact, cardamom is still used in many parts of the world today to freshen breath. You’ll even find it included in some brands of chewing gum. Studies have also confirmed these health benefits of cardamom, showing that this unique spice is a natural antiseptic and can kill the oral bacteria that cause gingivitis, cavities, and bad breath. A little more bang for your buck in recipes!

How Do You Describe the Flavor of Cardamom (and What Dishes Is It Used In?)

Cardamom has a unique flavor, unlike any other spice. In general, cardamom is described as potent, sharp, sweet, ashy, spicy, warming, and aromatic. Due to its strength, a little goes a long way. Cardamom comes in different varieties: green, white, black, and in its whole or powder form.

When it comes to the powder versus the whole spice, whole cardamom seeds and pods will always be stronger tasting than the ground spice, which loses some of its pungency after grinding. If you happen to have cardamom powder on hand, note that it can be ideal for lighter dishes where you don’t want to create an overpowering flavor, such as desserts and baked goods.

Note that each variety of cardamom tastes different, so it helps to understand how each type varies, so that you know which cardamom replacement is most appropriate for your dish.

Green Cardamom vs. Black Cardamom vs. White Cardamom: Why Knowing the Three Different Types of Cardamom Matters

What Does Green Cardamom Taste Like?

green cardamom

Green cardamom is described as tasting like an “earthy ginger”: sweet, zesty, spicy, with subtle hints of citrus. When green cardamom is used in recipes, you can use both the pods and the seeds for flavoring. Just be sure to discard the inedible fibrous green cardamom pods before serving. You can also grind the seeds in a coffee grinder or with a mortar and pestle before adding them to your recipe.

You’ll find green cardamom in chicken and red meat dishes, curries, stews, and desserts, such as Kulfi (an Indian dessert consisting of frozen custard), mulled wine, chai, pistachio-inspired desserts, and sugar cookies. Green cardamom also pairs well with other warming spices like nutmeg and cinnamon. While it’s certainly pungent, green cardamom is more delicate than black cardamom which has an intense, smoky flavor.

What Does Black Cardamom Taste Like?

black cardamom

Black cardamom pods have smoky undertones with a sharp menthol flavor, which is why you’ll mostly find this variety in savory dishes such as stews, curries, marinades, and spice blends like garam masala—and not so much in sweet dishes. Due to its intense taste, it’s not as versatile as green cardamom for different types of recipes.

Since black cardamom is so pungent, it’s recommended to balance it out in recipes with warming spices like cinnamon, chilis, Sichuan peppercorns, cloves, allspice, or ginger.

What Does White Cardamom Taste Like?

white cardamom

White cardamom is just green cardamom that’s been bleached to tone down its flavor. So, it has the same flavor profile as green cardamom but is more mild and delicate. It can be used in any dishes you’d use green cardamom in, including desserts, meat dishes, and chai.

What’s the Best Cardamom Substitute?

Some spices can be hard to mimic and find accurate substitutes for. Luckily with cardamom’s warming, sweet, zesty, and spicy flavor profile, there are a few aromatics with similar properties that can step in and do the trick.

1. Cinnamon

ground cinnamon and cinnamon sticks

Cinnamon is widely regarded as the best stand-alone cardamom substitute. It’s warming, slightly citrusy and sweet with hints of spice.

How to substitute: One teaspoon of ground cardamom = one teaspoon of ground cinnamon.

2. Nutmeg

If you don’t have cinnamon, nutmeg is the next best stand-alone cardamom substitute. It’s warm and slightly sweet, with a hint of nutty, woody flavor. While it’s not an exact match to cardamom, it embodies the sweet and warming qualities which can help you achieve a similar flavor in sweet and savory recipes.

How to substitute: One teaspoon of ground cardamom = one teaspoon of ground nutmeg.

3. Nutmeg and Cinnamon

Since cardamom has a lot of depth, using both nutmeg and cinnamon together can help achieve a little more complex flavor. If you have both spices on hand, you may want to use equal parts of both, rather than nutmeg or cinnamon on its own.

How to substitute: One teaspoon of ground cardamom = ½ teaspoon of ground cinnamon + ½ teaspoon of ground nutmeg.

4. Ground Cloves and Cinnamon or Ground Cloves and Nutmeg

If you’re looking for more intensity, combining cloves with cinnamon or nutmeg is another great cardamom substitute. Cloves bring the intense, warming, ashy, and pungent properties of cardamom, while cinnamon or nutmeg step in to bring extra warmth and sweetness.

How to substitute: One teaspoon of ground cardamom = ½ teaspoon of ground cloves + ½ teaspoon of ground cinnamon or nutmeg

5. Cinnamon and Ginger

ground ginger

The warmth and sweetness of cinnamon, combined with the sharp, spicy, peppery, sweet taste of ginger do a good job of creating a similar flavor profile to cardamom.

How to substitute: One teaspoon of ground cardamom = ½ teaspoon of ground cinnamon + ½ teaspoon of ground ginger.

6. Allspice

Allspice is fragrant, sharp, and slightly fruity, described as having the flavor of black pepper, cloves, nutmeg, and cinnamon. Allspice is milder than cardamom, but it still works well in recipes as a substitute. If you wanted to give the allspice substitute a little more complexity, you could experiment by combining it with ½ or ¼  teaspoon of cinnamon, ginger, or cloves.

How to substitute: One teaspoon of ground cardamom = one teaspoon of ground allspice

(Optional to add ¼ teaspoons of other suggested spices, to taste). 

7. Apple Pie Spice

Cardamom is one of the ingredients in apple pie spice, along with ground cinnamon, ginger, and nutmeg. So if you’re really in a pinch (or especially if you’re making a dessert), you can use apple pie spice in place of cardamom. It will just be milder and slightly sweeter.

How to substitute: One teaspoon of ground cardamom = one teaspoon of apple pie spice.

8. Cumin and Coriander

For those savory recipes like Indian stews, curries, soups, and meat dishes, cumin and coriander can achieve a similar earthy, warming profile to cardamom. You can use either ground cumin and coriander or cumin and coriander seeds.

How to substitute: One teaspoon of ground cardamom = ½ teaspoon ground cumin + ½ teaspoon ground coriander. 

The Takeaway

Cardamom is a unique, sharp, and pungent spice that’s used in sweet and savory recipes, including desserts, baking, meat dishes, stews, and curries. It comes in three different varieties: green, black, and white. Green cardamom (while still pungent), is milder and more delicate than black cardamom, which has a sharp, ashy, menthol flavor.

If your recipe calls for green cardamom, the best cardamom substitute is equal parts cinnamon, equal parts nutmeg, or ½ teaspoon of cinnamon and ½ teaspoon of nutmeg. You could also add cloves to cinnamon or nutmeg for more intensity (which can mimic similar properties of black cardamom but is still mild enough to use in dessert recipes).

7 Close Seconds to the Best Cardamom Substitute for When You’re in a Pinch
What’s the Best Cardamom Substitute? Here are 7 Close Seconds for When You’re in a Pinch

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.