Here are the best bay leaf substitutes to pull from your spice rack when you’re all out. Also learn how to substitute for dried, fresh, and ground bay leaves.

fresh bay leaves in a bowl

If your recipe calls for a single whole bay leaf and you don’t have one, you may be tempted to just leave it out. How much of a difference could one tiny leaf really make?

While this slightly minty, peppery Mediterranean herb may seem underwhelming, it does an excellent job at enhancing and balancing bold, heavy flavors in savory sauces, soups (like Asian-style borscht), stews, and meat dishes. 

Bay leaves can also transform a bland vegetable dish into a flavor bomb. Just take a peek at these braised leeks with white wine! With that said, if you can’t get your hands on a bay leaf, it’s worth using a bay leaf substitute to get as close as possible to the intended flavor of your dish. 

What Does Bay Leaf Taste Like?

two fresh bay leaves

Bay leaves have a strong flavor, a little bitter. They taste peppery and minty, with hints of pine, so that’s what you want to keep in mind when you choose a bay leaf substitute. There are no herbs or spices that replicate the exact flavor of a bay leaf— although some herbs embody a similar menthol, pepper, or “piney” taste and come close.

Due to their pungent nature, bay leaves are used sparingly. Typically, one bay leaf is more than enough to flavor an entire recipe. Bay leaves are stiff even after being slow-cooked for several hours, so they need to be removed and discarded before serving. Not only are they unpleasant to chew and eat whole, but they can also damage your digestive tract (so don’t forget to toss ‘em before dishing up).

As with most herbs, whole bay leaves have a stronger flavor than their crushed, dried counterparts. However, dried, crushed bay leaves will distribute more flavor throughout your whole dish, which can backfire and leave your recipe tasting too minty. Keep this in mind if you substitute ground bay leaves for a whole leaf. You’ll always want to start with a very tiny amount (exact measurements are listed below).

California Bay Leaves Vs. Turkish Bay Leaves

California bay leaves on the tree

There are two different types of bay leaves: Turkish bay leaves and California bay leaves. If your recipe doesn’t specify which variety to use, it’s probably a fresh or dried Turkish bay leaf you’d be after. Turkish bay leaves grow on the Mediterranean bay laurel tree. They’re also known as laurel leaves.

Turkish bay leaves are sweeter and milder, which is why they’re the preferred cooking variety. California bay leaves grow on the California bay tree and have a strong eucalyptus, minty flavor. If you find fresh bay leaves in North America, they’re most likely California bay leaves and will have a sharper taste.

If you come across an Indian bay leaf, it’s a different species entirely. An Indian bay leaf tastes like cloves, cinnamon, and allspice, so it won’t work as a bay leaf substitute. But it can certainly work in Caribbean sauces and curries, and homemade aromatic teas.

Can You Substitute Fresh, Dried, and Ground Bay Leaves?

fresh bay leaves on a plate

Since fresh, dried, and ground bay leaves have different potencies, you don’t want to substitute them in equal amounts. Here’s how to swap fresh, dried, and ground bay leaves to match their intended taste.

One fresh bay leaf = two dried bay leaves.
One dried bay leaf = ¼ tsp ground bay leaves.
One fresh bay leaf = ½ tsp ground bay leaves.

What’s the Best Bay Leaf Substitute? 5 Options for When You’re Out

1. Dried Thyme

dried thyme with dried bay leaves and cinnamon sticks

Dried thyme is the best bay leaf substitute. Although bay leaves and thyme look nothing alike, dried thyme is also from the Mediterranean region and has a similar, subtle minty flavor. Dried thyme works best as a bay leaf substitute in recipes that use beef and lamb.

How to substitute:

  • 1 bay leaf = ¼ teaspoon dried thyme
  • ¼ teaspoon crushed bay leaf = ¼ teaspoon dried thyme

2. Basil

dried basil from a jar

As a member of the mint family, basil can work as a bay leaf substitute. It also has bitter and peppery notes. However, fresh basil is not an exact substitute for a bay leaf because it also has a hint of anise, which is sweet and tastes like licorice. When dried, basil loses the strong anise notes, so it tastes closer to a bay leaf.

Dried basil is a good substitute for bay leaves in Thai, Italian, and other tomato-based dishes, like pasta sauces and stews.

How to substitute:

  • 1 bay leaf = 1 basil leaf
  • ¼ teaspoon crushed bay leaf = ¼ teaspoon dried basil 

3. Oregano 

a spoonful of dried oregano

As another bitter, pungent, and slightly minty herb (and one that’s very easy to find), dried oregano can also work as a bay leaf substitute. Like basil, using oregano as a bay leaf substitute will work best in tomato-based dishes and recipes that use beef and lamb.

How to substitute:

  • 1 bay leaf = ¼ teaspoon dried oregano
  • ¼ teaspoon crushed bay leaf = ¼ teaspoon dried oregano

4. Juniper Berries 

Juniper berries with spoons

Juniper berries have notes of pine and pepper, which make them an unsuspecting but effective bay leaf substitute. Small but mighty, juniper berries also have a strong, overwhelming taste, so they need to be used sparingly. They’re safe to eat, but you can use them whole and discard them before serving (as you would a bay leaf) or grind them before tossing them in to help release their flavor.

How to substitute:

  • 1 bay leaf = two or three juniper berries (ground or whole) 

5. Boldo Leaves

dried Boldo leaves in a wooden bowl and on a spoon

Boldo leaves are native to Chile and grow on the boldo plant. They’re slightly bitter, rich, and savory, but have an all-around softer taste than bay leaves—which allows them to work well in flavoring lighter recipes, such as mushroom and vegetable-based dishes. Boldo leaves can still be overpowering when used in large amounts, so it’s recommended to substitute at even just half the ratio that the recipe calls for and work your way up from there.

How to substitute:

  • 1 bay leaf = ½ boldo leaf 
  • ½ teaspoon crushed bay leaf = ¼ teaspoon crushed boldo leaf

The Takeaway

If you’re out of fresh, dried, or ground bay leaves, thyme is the next best thing to a bay leaf. With a similar potent minty taste and also used liberally in Mediterranean cooking, thyme can replace a bay leaf in meat and pasta dishes without compromising the flavor.

If you don’t have thyme, basil and oregano are next in line and work best as bay leaf substitutes in lamb, beef, and tomato dishes. Juniper berries and boldo leaves can also mimic some of the flavors in a bay leaf but aren’t always easy to find in grocery stores.

The Best Bay Leaf Substitute (5 Options) - Pin

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *